
The Astoria has real strengths — location, staff, cleanliness — but room quality is wildly inconsistent: some are spacious and bright, others are tiny, dark, and smell odd. Noise bleed through walls and windows is a recurring complaint, and a handful of serious incidents (card theft, privacy breach, cockroaches in 2023) add enough uncertainty to warrant caution.
🚩 Red Flags
“Staff opened our room in the middle of the night and brought a drunk person unknown to us into our room, very odd.”
“I think the bathroom needs a little updating, overall it was clean but there was a bit of mould on the walls and the shower head was very old and broken. I recommend this hotel!”
“I had my card stolen from the room and the hotel management was extremely rude and unhelpful about it. This was one of our worst stays.”
“La cucarachas in bathroom, very loud water system of neighbors rooms, very loud neighbors.”
“Our room was super small especially for two people with luggage. The tub was extremely narrow, you could not stand comfortably in the shower.”
“Room too small. No room for our suitcases. No tea/coffee making in the room. Not great value for money.”
“I was first presented with the opposite of what I requested — having neither view, high floor, nor light — in a room that needed some maintenance.”
“300 euros a night, a mediocre breakfast and a small room without a window. Does that need any more words?”
“No view from window, lack of natural light, construction work noises, old elevator, old shower.”
“The bedroom was very small and there was basically no view.”
“Sound insulation is poor — you can hear noise from the corridor and through the windows.”
“You could hear when they showered, talked and used the hairdryer in the next room.”
“Side and upper rooms, sounds came through very clearly.”
“In the corridor of my floor there was a very unpleasant smell, similar to sewage. I suppose that...”
“Unpleasant smell in the room and bathroom.”
“Rooms not well ventilated with a humid smell coming from the bathroom.”
“The pool is really small and has just three sunbeds. Not enough for many guests to enjoy after a hot day of touring.”
“If you want a lounger you have to get there early, there are only a handful.”
“Pool closed at 9. A few staff were short with us.”
“Breakfast for €16 per person is over exaggerated! We found food outside of the hotel for half that price.”
“Nearly €20 per person for the selection offered is quite expensive.”
“The breakfast was priced about evenly with a hotel in Naples; however, the selection for the cost was extremely limited.”
“Would have liked a water kettle for coffee and coffee and sugar packets.”
“No kettle for coffee or coffee packets and room delivery of food was expensive and not tasty.”
“Personally it would have been nice to have coffee/tea making facilities in the room as I love my morning hot drink in bed.”