
The Hudson Saltbox is the rare Airbnb that actually looks better in person than in the photos. Eighty consecutive 10/10 reviews tell a consistent story: impeccable design, luxurious linens, a heated pool and cedar hot tub, and hosts (Jane and Steven) who set the gold standard for thoughtful hospitality. The only minor quirks — a slightly finicky fireplace and a faint sulfur smell from hot tap water — are the kind of things you'd mention to a friend as a footnote, not a warning.
🚩 Red Flags
“There was a slight sulfur smell when using hot water from the tap or in the showers, but it wasn't a major issue for us.”
“The fireplace is a little finnicky to set up and get venting properly, but we still enjoyed a couple nights sitting by the fire.”
“The only difference was my expectation for a partially fenced in property for my dog. Only the pool deck was fenced in but it worked out okay.”
“Despite the listing stating that the pool is heated and available all year, we were informed on arrival day that this is not the case. We would have appreciated an earlier heads up during the booking process or earlier that the listed amenity wasn't available.”
“We encountered some heating issues but the host was able to resolve them timely.”